No Margin, No Mission: The 5 Moves That Turned a $1 Million Deficit Into Millions in the Reserves

October 26, 2026•7 min read

By Jill Steeley, former FQHC CEO, executive coach, and host of The Community Health Collective podcast

I'm Jill Steeley. Before I coached health center leaders, I sat in the CEO seat of what's now PureView Health Center in Helena, Montana. I inherited nearly a $1 million deficit and left the organization with millions in the reserves. Last spring I joined Jeremy and Kathryn Zugg on The Claim Game podcast to talk about how we did it, and this week I'm replaying that conversation on The Community Health Collective. Here's the core of it, written for the health center leader who'd rather read than listen.

In this post:

  • Why "run it like a business" isn't a betrayal of your mission

  • The five moves I used to turn around a struggling health center

  • What no-shows and turnover are really costing you

  • Why your health center's name might be hurting your payer mix

  • How to use AI without cutting your people

  • The KPI mistake almost every health center makes

Can a nonprofit health center be profitable and still serve the underserved?

Yes. And it has to be.

When I took over, we were a co-applicant health center and a county department, and the unspoken belief was "if we serve the poor, we should be poor too." It sounds humble. It sounds mission-aligned. But it's how health centers end up surviving grant cycle to grant cycle, one funding fight away from closing the doors.

Here's my take: you attract people with a payer, and you serve people with a payer, so you can serve the people without one.

No margin, no mission. If the doors close, you serve no one.

At PureView, we served more uninsured patients after the turnaround, not fewer. Our patient count doubled. That's what a strong margin buys you.

What does it take to turn around a struggling FQHC?

Here's what I walked into on day one:

1. Nearly a $1 million deficit, and it was growing every day

2. No medical doctor recruited in five years

3. A closed dental clinic, because we couldn't recruit a dentist

4. Declining patient numbers every year

5. A payer mix with about 42% of patients uninsured

6. A reputation that we only served the poor

And here are the five moves that turned it around. They're the same ones Steve Weinman and I now teach in the FQHC CEO Connect Bootcamp:

1. Increase and diversify revenue. For 12 months, I spoke anywhere they'd have me - civic groups, churches, other nonprofits' staff meetings. We signed large employers to make us their preferred primary care provider, which brought in privately insured employees and their families.

2. Reduce costs by plugging the leaks. Revenue growth doesn't help if the money's walking out the back door.

3. Market and brand the health center. We rebranded and saturated the market with our new name and what we did.

4. Create an exceptional patient experience. From the first phone call to the follow-up after the visit.

5. Keep the momentum. No pulling one lever and coasting until the next funding cycle.

How much are no-shows and staff turnover costing my health center?

Probably more than you think. No-shows cost the healthcare industry an estimated $150 billion a year. At the health center level, the math looks like this:

  • 10,000 Medicaid visits a year

  • A 20% no-show rate (common, especially in behavioral health)

  • A $200 reimbursement rate

  • That's 2,000 missed visits and $400,000 a year - plus the provider you're still paying and the patient who couldn't get that slot

Turnover is the other big leak. Replacing an employee costs 50% to 250% of their salary. Lose one provider, and it costs you a couple hundred thousand dollars at least.

The problems I see most often:

1. No-show rates nobody is actively working to bring down

2. Turnover treated as a cost of doing business instead of a fixable leak

3. Cutting staff first when money gets tight - which leaves you understaffed, seeing fewer patients, and bringing in less revenue

4. Schedules and staffing levels that don't match each other

The solutions:

1. Make your no-show rate a number your leadership team owns, and give your team the tools to reduce it

2. Invest in recruiting and retaining high-quality staff, including professional growth for everyone, not just providers

3. Fix the leaks before you cut

4. Optimize staffing levels and patient schedules together

Does marketing really matter for a community health center?

It matters more than almost anything. When we surveyed our community before our rebrand, only 23% recognized our name. And most of those people thought we were the county health department and only did travel vaccinations.

We were in a deficit, and we spent real money on a rebrand and marketing campaign anyway, because I knew we couldn't afford not to. A couple of years later, brand recognition was over 90%, and almost everyone knew what we did, who we served, and that we took all insurance.

Think about it. Nobody plans a doctor's appointment six months out. When you need one, you need one. You Google it, or you call the place whose name is already in your head. You want to be that place.

How can an FQHC attract more privately insured and Medicare patients?

Start by looking like a place people with a payer would choose.

Health centers are in a great position to attract Medicare patients. Many private practices cap how many they'll see, and retiring providers leave Medicare patients looking for a new home. Medicare is also a strong payer for health centers because of the PPS rate.

Then look hard at your name. We were "Cooperative Health Center," which sounded like government healthcare. We became PureView Health Center. Ask yourself:

1. Does our name sound like a government program?

2. Does it name one faith, culture, or group in a way that makes others feel they don't belong?

3. Would a working family with commercial insurance assume they're welcome?

How should a health center CEO use AI right now?

I hear "I don't think we're there yet" a lot. But AI isn't going away, and it can save you a lot of money. The best uses I see right now:

  • AI scribes that also suggest the right billing code for the provider to approve

  • AI for coding, claims recovery, and billing

  • AI agents that call insurance companies about prior authorizations and denied claims, and transfer to a human when they get stuck

  • Chatbots and AI receptionists for scheduling and reminders, including after hours

I'm not suggesting you fire half your staff. But the next time someone leaves a role that was mostly manual entry and phone tag, try the technology before you backfill the job. Replace obsolete tasks, not people.

Which KPIs should a health center leader actually track?

It's less about tracking the wrong things and more about when you look. Most health centers only look at their HRSA-required measures once a year, when the annual report is due. That's driving by the rearview mirror.

Instead:

1. Decide where you want your health center to be in one to three years

2. Identify the data that tells you, every month, whether you're getting there

3. Review it monthly, so you can fix a problem now instead of discovering it 12 months later

What's coming for health centers in 2027?

Medicaid changes. More fights over funding. But I'm not doom and gloom. People are tired of transactional healthcare, and health centers are some of the best places to get transformational care. If your community knows you exist, they'll come. If they don't, they won't. So get in front of them, have them pick you, and then dazzle them so they keep coming back.

Listen to the full conversation

The full replay of my interview on The Claim Game is on this week's episode of The Community Health Collective. And if you're ready to move your health center out of survival mode, let's talk. You canschedule a call with meor learn more about the FQHC CEO Connect Bootcamp at www.fqhc-ceo.com.

You're not doing this alone.

- Jill Steeley

About the Author

Jill Steeley is the host of the Community Health Collective Podcast and an executive coach to leaders across community health centers, FQHCs, and mission-driven healthcare organizations. After two decades inside the healthcare leadership world and close to 250 healthcare leaders coached and mentored, she helps healthcare executives build the leadership skills they were never formally taught - and helps full leadership teams shift culture together rather than one leader at a time.

Learn more at jillsteeley.com.

Back to Blog